How Can I Make Coffee That Tastes Like Cake?

Ever wondered if your coffee could taste exactly like your favourite dessert?

You're not alone. Sometimes, regular coffee just doesn't hit the spot. I've often found myself craving a coffee that's sweet and rich, like chocolate cake or cinnamon rolls. Luckily, creating coffee that tastes like cake isn't as tricky as it sounds.

Flavour Your Coffee Like a Dessert

Turning your morning coffee into a dessert experience doesn't have to involve complicated recipes. I found it's all about choosing the right ingredients. Start by selecting quality coffee beans—freshness makes a huge difference. Then, you simply add flavours that mimic your favourite cakes.

[collection-carousel="coffee"]

If chocolate cake is your thing, try adding cocoa powder or a chocolate syrup directly into your coffee. I usually mix a teaspoon or two right into my brewed coffee, stirring until it’s smooth. For something extra indulgent, add whipped cream on top. Trust me, it’s worth it.

Want more ideas on flavouring coffee? Here's another handy guide that I found really helpful.

Spice Things Up

Cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla are your best friends if you love cake-flavoured coffee. What I've seen is that a dash of cinnamon or nutmeg brings a warm, bakery-like flavour. Sprinkle it straight into the coffee grounds before brewing, or add it after brewing.

Vanilla extract is another great way to get a deliciously sweet taste without adding heaps of sugar. Just a few drops will do the trick. I've also used almond extract, and it tastes just like a slice of almond cake.

Milk Makes the Magic Happen

Ever wondered why café coffee feels richer? It’s usually because of creamy, frothed milk. If you're craving something creamy and dessert-like, use whole milk or even plant-based alternatives like oat milk. Warm it gently and use a milk pitcher or handheld frother to create perfect, silky foam.

[collection-carousel="milk-pitchers"]

If you’re curious about latte art, practising with a milk pitcher will quickly improve your skills. It’s easier than you think and adds an extra touch of café-style indulgence.

Coffee Cake in a Cup

One of my favourite combinations is coffee that mimics the classic coffee cake. You know, the crumbly, cinnamon-spiced treat. Simply sprinkle a little cinnamon into your coffee grounds before brewing. You can even top your brewed coffee with whipped cream and more cinnamon. It tastes exactly like coffee cake in liquid form!

For inspiration, here's a list of delicious coffee cake recipes that pair beautifully with your cake-flavoured coffee.

Chocolate Coffee Heaven

I noticed chocolate is a universally loved flavour among coffee drinkers—especially Australians who enjoy their mocha coffees. You can make your coffee taste just like a slice of rich chocolate cake by adding cocoa powder directly into the coffee grounds or stirring in chocolate syrup after brewing.

It's also great iced. Just pour your brewed coffee over ice, add a dash of milk or cream, and chocolate syrup. You'll have yourself a deliciously decadent iced mocha that tastes like dessert.

Cold Brew Dessert Delights

Cold brew coffee naturally has a sweeter, smoother taste. It pairs beautifully with dessert-inspired flavours. My favourite trick is to prepare a batch of cold brew overnight in the fridge, adding vanilla or caramel syrup the next day. It feels like enjoying dessert for breakfast. Using good coffee scales makes measuring easy and precise.

If cold brew sounds tempting, here's a great resource on pairing desserts with coffee, giving you plenty of sweet inspiration.

Coffee and Dessert Fusion at Home

Combining coffee with dessert flavours doesn’t need to be complicated. A simple way is to blend ice cream or gelato with freshly brewed espresso—a classic affogato. Vanilla gelato is the classic choice, but chocolate or salted caramel ice cream works brilliantly too. This instantly satisfies that dessert-coffee craving.

I've found this affogato recipe particularly easy to follow.

Cake-Flavoured Coffee Hacks

If you're in a rush, flavoured syrups can save the day. Popular cake-inspired syrups include caramel, vanilla, chocolate fudge, and even birthday cake flavour. Just a quick drizzle or two, and your coffee is dessert-ready.

Flavoured coffees taste best when using manual brewing methods because you can control the strength and flavour balance perfectly. If you prefer manual brewing, check out our manual brew equipment. 

[collection-carousel="manual-brew"]

Your Coffee, Your Way

The beauty of making coffee at home is that you control everything. Play around with different flavours, sweetness levels, and brewing methods until you find your perfect dessert-like coffee.

Need help choosing flavours or want to share your coffee creations? We love hearing from fellow coffee enthusiasts. Feel free to reach out anytime!

Written By Laurie Nance

I'm the founder of Brewedco Coffee™, passionate about coffee, coffee tools, and helping others better understand how to utilize them. With years of experience in the coffee industry, I love sharing insights on brewing techniques, choosing the right equipment, and the science behind making the perfect cup.